C & H Bait & Tackle Convenience, 5507 Teals Mill Road, Teals Mill: between 2007 and 2018
I'm pretty sure this old convenience store and gas station by the old bridge in Teals Mill had existed under a different name or two prior to becoming C & H Bait & Tackle Convenience in 2001. The style of gas pump that can be seen in the above pictures would not have been installed at a gas station that was being constructed in the 21st century.
As for when this store closed, I am not sure. The gas pump shows $2.899 per gallon for 89 octane (i.e. midgrade) gas. That gas price could have been found at various times between 2007 and 2018 based on the average gas prices per year.
Even though the road has been moved a bit to cross the new bridge, the store front is still accessible and close enough to the road to be seen for any business that may set up shop here in the future.